Charlotte Goodwin
  • Home
  • About
  • Books
    • The Homecoming Trilogy >
      • Sample the Queen of Vorn, here
    • The Offspring Trilogy
    • Short Stories
  • Children's Stories
    • Mike the Baby Mammoth
    • Sam the Smilodon
    • Gary the Ground Sloth
    • Ben the Cave Bear
    • Sam the Stegosaurus
    • Rob the Rat Wizard
  • Contact
  • Home
  • About
  • Books
    • The Homecoming Trilogy >
      • Sample the Queen of Vorn, here
    • The Offspring Trilogy
    • Short Stories
  • Children's Stories
    • Mike the Baby Mammoth
    • Sam the Smilodon
    • Gary the Ground Sloth
    • Ben the Cave Bear
    • Sam the Stegosaurus
    • Rob the Rat Wizard
  • Contact
Search by typing & pressing enter

YOUR CART

Picture
Picture
find out more...

THE QUEEN OF VORN HAS BEEN UN-PUBLISHED

Following a recent Twitter storm involving the author, The Queen of Vorn has been review-bombed.  This has reduced the star-average significantly when compared to reviews from genuine readers. Please read the blog post below for more details.

The author is also conscious that perhaps The Queen of Vorn was released a little early, and perhaps could be better with a few tweaks while it would also benefit from a fresh start with a clean slate.  As such, she has made the decision to un-publish this book and cancel the release of its sequels until further notice.


To be the first to hear about when the three books in The Homecoming Trilogy will be once again be available to order, please sign up to the author's newsletter by clicking the link below.
subscribe to the newsletter

Author's Blog

12/5/2025 8 Comments

When the trolls strike...

Picture
​I wanted a bit of publicity – I got it.
 
I also got countless messages spouting hate and making slanderous comments about me and my books. I got review-bombed mostly on Goodreads, but with a few on Amazon too.
 
My crime?
 
Being upset about a review that wasn’t what I’d hoped for, and saying so publicly.
 
That was where it all started, at least.
 
Here’s the post: 
Picture
The post caused a lot of discussion, and the vast majority of the posts on it were encouraging and nice.  But there were a few nasty highlights.  I blocked most of the posters of this stuff, so I can’t see it anymore, but it seems they keep coming;  here’s one:
 
“Don’t come on Twitter and cry about getting a three star review.  Be glad you got a review and be glad they were constructive.  Stop being such an egotistical idiot.”
 
So posts like these don’t bother me too much, and I could shrug it all off, but one of the kind of people who decided my post was a bit too much for them, decided to do some trawling of my Twitter/X account.  They found a reply to a post I wrote some time ago where I stated a few facts they didn’t like.  Having written a book that features actual genocide, I (foolishly) decided to correct someone who was making an inaccurate statement. I stated the following:
 
“There is no genocide in Palestine, The definition of genocide is “The deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group””
 
I also stated a few other objective facts about the war.  The original post got a tiny handful of views.  No-one really cared, but now?  It was tagged to my original post about my review and got swept amongst the pro-Palestine lot.  Oh dear, they are a very passionate bunch.
 
It seems there is also another issue too – the same lovely person who found my historic tweet and decided to tell the world that I’m a Zionist, also said my cover was made by AI; which to be honest, I can’t categorically say is incorrect as I didn’t do the bulk of the design work myself.  But what I can say is that I paid a designer to make it and I don’t know for certain where she got her imagery from.  But I also got the Photoshop files and I know there is a load of layers, lots of adjustments and a hell of a lot of design work in there regardless. 
 
Anyway, I was now guilty of several crimes in the view of the Twitter mob, and so they descended.
 
My post is clearly still rattling around the internet, as the review bombing continues.  Here’s how it looks now:
Picture
I reported a load of reviews, and some were removed, but a load more have appeared.
 
Here are a collection of the highlights:

 
“Ai cover art, author is a zionist, poor writing and a rude author who feels entitled to only 5 star reviews immediately after publishing?? Girl be for real.”
 
“AI cover + rude, entitled, immature and self-absorbed author, one star is honestly far too generous of a rating for this book”
 
“AI cover is enough to not touch this shitty shit with 10 foot pole but the whole tantrums over readers not rating the way you like speaks a whole another entitlement. I won't even consider pirating it, let alone encourage my reader friends to read it and spend money on it."
 
“I've never read it but her attitude on Twitter is deplorable AND the ai cover is fugly”
 
“weirdass freak author"

 
The three-star review that kicked this all off really upset me, and I said as much online.  Having thought about why, I realised it was mainly because it made me doubt my own work.  I have put an awful lot of time, effort and money into that book, and I wanted it to be read by as many people as possible – but not just read, enjoyed.  But these troll reviews?  They don’t bother me quite so much as I know they aren’t from people who have read my book.
 
I write for a lot of reasons, but mainly, I write so I can give pleasure to others.  So when I think I haven’t delighted them as much as I’d hoped, it upsets me.  But I got even more upset by the idea that this review would put off future readers, so fewer people would subsequently read my work, and fewer people would enjoy it.
 
According to some, admitting this in public is a heinous crime, and I should be immediately ridiculed and abused.
 
As for the AI cover and Palestine stuff – I get those topics are very divisive and there are some very strong opinions on the subject.  I regret breaking my own rule of not engaging in political posts on this rare occasion for this exact reason.  As for AI?  I would never read an AI written book, because I like to read something that a human has created.  But I can’t say I’m anti AI in general.  It’s a very saturated market; editors, designers and marketing are expensive.  If we use a little AI to help us, is that a problem?  I think it’s a tool.  I know some people disagree and I respect that, but is it worth trying to destroy me as an author because you disagree with my opinions?
 
I’ve heard about other people being mobbed on Twitter, but I never thought it would happen to me.  Now it has. 
 
I’ve had plenty of people telling me how I should react, too.  And I agree with those who tell me to ignore most of it and wait for the twitter storm to die down.  But I can’t do nothing.  I want to at least highlight how seemingly innocuous things can blow up.  How past moments of carelessness can result in you being kicked when you’re down.  How the mob can descend and shout “Kill the Witch!”

​My anxiety has flared up and I couldn’t do any of the work I’d planned to do yesterday on my audiobook because I was on edge all day.  I couldn’t sleep.  I still have a massive lump in my stomach and I wish this whole debacle would just go away.  I'm sure it will in time I just hope the damage isn't permanent.
 
So now what?
 
I wait for the storm to die down and carry on.  What else can I do?

And if you're wondering, this is what the people who have read my book and aren't trolls say, including the review that started all this off, here's a collection:
Picture
8 Comments
Todd link
12/5/2025 02:59:39 pm

I take it you are recording your own audiobook? That is very cool. I had not heard of you before the brouhaha, but I wanted to offer words of encouragement. You did something many people only talk about doing but never take the time to actually do. You deserve some congratulations and encouragement. I truly hope things turn around.

Reply
Charlotte Goodwin
12/5/2025 05:16:29 pm

I've done the initial recording and am now editing it. It's a bit of a slog, so I hope it will be worth it.

Thanks for your nice words. Luckily people like you far out number the haters!

Reply
Andy Houstoun
12/5/2025 04:33:29 pm

I know how you feel. One of my books was given out free for people who were interested, with the intention of receiving getting reviews. One person said it wasn’t their cup of tea and gave me a one star review on Amazon.
The Twitter storm you’ve created is something else.
Good luck to you.👍

Reply
Charlotte Goodwin
12/5/2025 05:19:24 pm

Thanks, it seems lots of people have had spiteful reviews, its a shame people want to do that.

But I know there are far more good people out there than trolls, so hopefully, once all this blows over the bad reviews will (eventually) be outnumbered by the good ones.

Reply
Mark
12/5/2025 05:20:30 pm

I quite like the cover. Who gives a crap if it's partly AI? I'm sorry for this trouble you're going through. Bright side: I had never heard of you before, and now I have!

On another note: I have noticed (without having gone through what you are) that when I have bad feelings about some online interaction I am never more than 3 days from feeling just fine about it. Doesn't help a ton in the moment, and I realize this is probably a series of ongoing interactions, but there is hope. All the best.

Reply
Patrick
13/5/2025 09:00:01 pm

The 1-star review bombers are easy to spot and most readers won't pay them any mind. Regarding your online comments, you might consider posting a heartfelt apology. Some followers might have a genuine bad impression from those posts, even after they've been deleted. An apology could go a long way to restoring their good will. And those who aren't mollified won't care anyway, so no loss.

Reply
Sarah
31/5/2025 07:43:19 am

I am one of your Twitter followers, as a fellow writer, and feel terrible what you are going through right now. Everyone makes mistakes, and someone shouldn't be punished forever or canceled for a mere mistake. Things will blow over--there will be some new drama in the Writer Twitterverse to take this one's place, and this will be forgotten. Your book is not ruined. You are not ruined. My advice would be to shrug things off and carry on as a happy warrior; don't let the trolls know they've gotten to you. Humility and self-reflection goes a long way when done sincerely. Wishing you all the best, and I look forward to picking up your book when I have a chance/have the money.

Reply
x
18/6/2025 03:21:07 pm

keep crying you zionist pathetic whore. nobody likes your books because you are a crappy writer now go and give your trashy books 5 stars

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Subscribe to Charlotte's newsletter for the chance to get free stuff!

    Thanks for subscribing!

    You will shortly receive an email asking you to confirm your details, don't forget to check your spam folder.


    Author

    Charlotte Goodwin is the author of the Gallantrian Legacy series.  A set of six books (and counting) set in a universe where magic is real, there's just not much of it on Earth.


    Archives

    May 2025
    December 2024
    October 2024
    August 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022

    Categories

    All

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.